The Best Refrigerator Pickles

The best Refrigerator Pickles hail from a cook in the Organic Valley kitchen at their corporate office in Wisconsin. Learn how to make these organic pickles that your whole family will become obsessed with!

If you're looking for more ingredient recipes check out some of my other favorites like Pickled Red Onions and Peppers, Homemade Garlic Herb Butter, or Homemade Ranch Seasoning Mix with No Sugar.

A Quick Look At The Recipe

• Recipe Name: The Best Refrigerator Pickles
• Ready In: 3 days
• Makes: 16 servings
• Main Ingredients: cucumbers,
• Flavor Profile: sweet, tangy
• Dietary Info: vegan, gluten free, no seed oils, eggless
• Difficulty: Easy!
• Why You’ll Love It: homemade pickles you can use on everything!

Why You'll Love This Recipe

• 7 Ingredients: This recipe is easy AF! You just need a few simple ingredients.
• 15 Minutes: Prep this in 15 minutes, then you just need to wait for them to pickle (the hardest part!).
• Homemade: When you make your own organic pickles you can exclude things like natural flavors, colors, and more that store bought pickles can have. Also, try my Pickled Red Onions and Peppers if you like making homemade pickles!
• Use on Everything: This easy recipe for refrigerator pickles can be used on literally everything! Add them into salads, onto sandwiches, onto burgers, hot dogs, and so much more. You can even just eat them out of the bowl. I love them in my Simple Green Salad With Homemade Dressing!

History of This Recipe

We were recently in Wisconsin visiting my friends at Organic Valley. One of the days we spent at their office in La Farge, Wisconsin. While we were at the office, we ate lunch at the Organic Valley cafeteria (which cooks 100% organic meals for their employees daily!).

We had steak sandwiches for lunch that day, and all their grassfed organic steak comes from Organic Valley cows just down the road. And it was beyond delicious. But what really stood out to me was these pickles that I just happened to add on top of my salad.

Delaney got them too, and we found ourselves not being able to stop talking about these pickles! I mean they were just organic pickles, but they were so good that we talked about them even after we got home. So, I emailed one of my friends at Organic Valley and asked her if she knew anyone who worked in the kitchen, and luckily, she did.

She introduced me to Cindy, an Organic Valley chef. And I asked Cindy if she wouldn’t mind sharing her refrigerator pickle recipe with me because I just wanted to make them for myself! Of course, she was happy to.

Because according to Cindy, “it should be enjoyed”. And I couldn’t agree with her more. And she also said I could share it with all of you! So, thank you Cindy for making these amazing refrigerator pickles and for sharing with all of us!

Interview with Cindy

Mimi: How long have you worked in the Organic Valley kitchen?

Cindy: I have worked in the OV kitchen for 5 1/2 plus years. I started here when the building first opened here in Cashton. Best decision I ever made to join the OV workplace.

M: Who or what inspired you to want to become a chef?

C: There were three people who influenced my love for cooking. Both my maternal and paternal grandma’s and my dad were great cooks!!!!! I spent a lot of time as a child with my grandparents. My grandma’s both loved to cook for the family, and I was allowed actually encouraged to be a part of cooking the meals. I have fond memories of time spent with them. Gathering vegetables from the garden and meat from the freezer to prepare the meal. The pickles were always one of my favorites.

So, when I stared working at OV in the kitchen as salad bar prep person, I decided to bring in some of grandma’s recipes – the pickle recipe being one of those. I never expected them to be the hit that they are. But when the croppies bring guests in those pickles are one of the things on the salad bar most commented about!

I really enjoy making people happy with the food I make. My dad loved to cook and was asked by many people to cook for events for them. He enjoyed making people happy by the food he made, so I guess I come by it naturally. 

M: What does it mean to you to work at OV?

C: It means a lot to me to work at OV as they have the same values that I was raised on. OV gives me the opportunity to grow in my job position, they are very supportive of ideas I come up with for the salad bar line. I simply couldn’t ask for a better place to work. OV allows me the freedom to be me!!!!

M: So, tell me the story behind these pickles, or pickled cucumbers, what do we call them?

C: We are going to call the pickle recipe Grandma Tillie’s Refrigerator Pickles. This recipe came from her family when she moved here from Germany with her husband Otto, my grandpa. She made these pickles with cucumbers from her garden. I remember helping pick the cucumbers, onion, and green peppers from the garden, and making the pickles with her and always loved eating them. I have very fond memories of spending time in the kitchen cooking as a child. Little did I know than that it would help mold me into the person I am today. 

M: Small world because I have a grandpa Otto too, and he was a butcher. It’s my dad’s middle name, and I loved the name so much, that my first dog was named Otto. He recently just passed, but was the love of my life!

C: Such a small world that you and I both have an Otto 🙂

Ingredients

• Cucumbers: I use organic large cucumbers, but smaller ones also work for smaller hamburger size pickles.
• Yellow Onion: I use organic yellow onion for flavor, white is also fine.
• Green Bell Pepper: I use organic green bell peppers because this is how I originally had this recipe. Green have a specific flavor, but any color also works.
• Cane Sugar: I use organic cane sugar as this is less processed than granulated white sugar. This is what makes pickles “pickled”. Sugar works with vinegar for the distinct pickled flavor.
• Celery Seed: I use organic celery seed which gives these flavor!

*For a full list of ingredients and measurements, visit the recipe card below.

Tips for The Best Refrigerator Pickles

• Make sure to slice cucumbers thin, the thinner the better!
• I use a big pyrex bowl for this recipe because it has a lid. This is the best way to store these in the fridge while they “marinate”.
• The pickles will shrink down as they sit in the fridge, so it may seem like the liquid is not covering them completely that's okay!
• I like to transfer pickles to mason jars after the pickling time. This allows me to store them in the fridge easier.

How to Make The Best Refrigerator Pickles

1. Don’t peel the cucumbers but slice them in thicker slices (about ¼-inch). You should have about 8 cups once sliced. Set aside. Cut the yellow onion, in half and then slice. Set aside. Cut the green pepper into strips, set aside.

2. In a large bowl, layer cucumbers first, then onion, then green pepper. Sprinkle the sea salt over the top.

3. Cover and let sit for 2 hours, then drain off liquid.

4. In a medium bowl, add the cane sugar, white vinegar, and celery seed and mix together. Pour over the cucumber mixture and mix well.

5. Let the veggies sit in the refrigerator for at least 2 to 3 days, stirring once day (this is the hardest part!).

6. After a couple days, they are ready to eat.

Ways To Enjoy

These homemade pickles are so tasty on their own! But, I also love serving them with these recipes:

• Organic Chicago Style Hot Dogs With Sauerkraut also have pickles, these are so good on them!
• Add them on top of Organic Turkey Burgers With Grilled Onions!
• Enjoy as a side with Turkey and Lamb Burgers With Dill Sauce.
• Love as a side with BBQ Turkey Avocado Wrap.
• I love eating with Healthy Honey Chicken Salad With Cranberries for a quick lunch!

Recpe FAQ's

Recipes to Serve With Pickles

Organic Chicago Style Hot Dogs With Sauerkraut

Organic Turkey Burgers With Grilled Onions

Simple Green Salad with Homemade Dressing

BBQ Turkey Avocado Wrap