Mimi's Organic Eats » Lunch & Dinner Recipes » Supreme Pizza Pot Pie

Supreme Pizza Pot Pie

This Supreme Pizza Pot Pie is exactly as it sounds – it is a supreme pizza baked into a pot pie! The best of both worlds. This pie is loaded with the traditional fixings for supreme pizza, but wrapped up in a buttery flaky pie crust for a cross between a deep dish pizza and pot pie.

If you're looking for more pizza recipes, check out my Thin Crust Pepperoni Pizza, Pizza Toast, or my BBQ Veggie Pizza.

make supreme pizza, supreme pizza pot pie

Three words – Supreme Pizza Pot Pie, okay four words. But pot pie is kind of like one word, don’t you think? I have been thinking of this recipe for Supreme Pizza Pot Pie for months and I’m finally sharing it with you now!

I had this idea months and months ago, maybe even last year who knows at this point. Because I always want pizza. And because it’s so fun to make supreme pizza at home, I thought this take on it would be amazing. And when I was visiting Organic Valley over the summer and noticed they had organic pepperonis, I knew it was time to make it!

So, my friends at Organic Valley were kind enough to provide me with Organic Valley Organic Pepperonis, Organic Valley Organic Valley Mozzarella, and Organic Valley Salted Butter for this recipe because they knew how excited I was to make it!

make supreme pizza, supreme pizza pot pie

Why You'll Love This Recipe

With pie season in full effect now, it’s the perfect time to share this Supreme Pizza Pot Pie recipe. If you want to make supreme pizza, but you are also craving pie, then this Supreme Pizza Pot Pie is the perfect recipe to make.

I start out with a buttery and flaky pie crust. Then I make my own Homemade Organic Italian Sausage with my favorite organic ground pork, by Organic Prairie. Once that is made, I roll out the pie crust. Add in the Homemade Organic Italian Sausage, tomato sauce, and classic supreme pizza veggies – green pepper, onion, and mushrooms. I mix in grated Organic Valley Mozzarella, and I top the pie with the top crust. The best part is topping it with more mozzarella, Organic Valley Pepperonis, and black olives.

This baby tastes like your favorite pizza. But it has all the pot pie vibes with a buttery and flaky crust. Add a little fresh grated Parmesan cheese and you have a dinner that everyone will ask for again and again! Plus, it reheats amazing as leftovers too!

make supreme pizza, supreme pizza pot pie

Ingredients for Supreme Pizza Pot Pie

Organic Valley Salted Butter

Cairnspring Mills Organic All Purpose Flour (use code MIMIORGANIC15 for 15% off your order!)

Homemade Organic Italian Sausage

Organic Valley Mozzarella

Organic Prairie Pepperoni

Organic Green Peppers

Organic Baby Bella Mushrooms

Organic Yellow Onion

Organic Black Olives

make supreme pizza, supreme pizza pot pie

Tools Needed

Digital Food Scale

Box Grater

9-Inch Pie Pan

Rolling Pin

Mixing Bowl

make supreme pizza, supreme pizza pot pie


What does supreme pizza have on it?

Supreme pizza is made up of red sauce, mozzarella cheese, green pepper, onions, mushrooms, black olives, and Italian sausage and/or pepperoni, some recipes might have one or the other or both.

Does supreme pizza have olives?

Yes, I think so! Most supreme pizza recipes use black olives. However, if you don’t like them, you can easily leave them off your pie as well. Everyone’s supreme pizza recipe will be slightly different, and some may leave the olives off, but they are traditionally on top.

Can I make this Supreme Pizza Pot Pie ahead of time?

Yes! This is a great make ahead recipe. If you are having a dinner party and you want to serve this, you can make it up to a day in advance. If you do this, leave off the mozzarella, pepperoni, and olives when you initially bake it. Then to reheat, bake at 350°F for 15 to 20 minutes, then add on your cheese, pepperoni, and olives and bake at 400°F for the additional 5 minutes.

Can I use grated cheese instead of grating my own?

Yes, if you prefer to buy organic grated cheese, you can do that as well. Organic Valley makes an Organic Shredded Mozzarella Cheese too. But check out my article on 5 Reasons to Grate Your Own Cheese.

Can I use different veggies?

Yes, if you want to use yellow, orange, or red peppers in place of green go for it! Or if you want to use yellow onion in place of red, go for it! Even veggies like zucchini would work in this recipe as the pie bakes for so long in the oven, they will cook just fine.

make supreme pizza, supreme pizza pot pie
make supreme pizza, supreme pizza pot pie

Why go organic?

You may be wondering why I push organic ingredients for everything, even savory and healthy dishes. Organic ingredients go beyond just health and wellness, and contribute so much to the taste and flavor of a recipe. So, if you think that you're making something healthy and buying fruits, veggies, or meats so maybe you don't need to spend the extra to go organic here – let me sway your thinking.

Organic ingredients are made in a more pure way, therefore using no additives, no GMOs, and minimal ingredients. This really allows the true ingredients to shine – and because of that their flavor shines through. Therefore, organic ingredients are more flavorful than their non organic counterparts. So, just because it's already a healthy recipe, or you're already buying good for you ingredients – it doesn't mean you can skip organic! Trust me here, and make the switch. Your body and your taste buds will thank you!

So, I highly recommend that you buy the best organic ingredients for this recipe! You can also shop my Amazon Storefront for all my favorite organic ingredients here. Tip – hover over each ingredient to see the name. And if you want to learn more about organic foods and the difference, read my post here on Food Labels and What They Mean.

make supreme pizza, supreme pizza pot pie
make supreme pizza, supreme pizza pot pie

Supreme Pizza Pot Pie

Mimi Council
Take pizza to the next level with this Supreme Pizza Pot Pie recipe! If you love pizza, and you love pie, then you will swoon over this new way to make supreme pizza at home!
Prep Time 30 minutes
Cook Time 1 hour 10 minutes
Chill Time 1 day
Total Time 1 day 1 hour 40 minutes
Course Main Course
Cuisine American
Makes 6 servings
Calories 615 kcal




  • 226 grams Homemade Organic Italian Sausage
  • 226 grams mozzarella cheese (grated, reserve ¾ cup for topping)
  • ½ cup tomato basil pasta sauce
  • ½ green pepper sliced
  • 2 slices red onion (cut in quarters)
  • 57 grams mushrooms (sliced)



  • To make the crust: In the bowl of a stand mixer fitted with the paddle attachment, add the flour.
  • Remove butter from the fridge and chop into small cubes, the smaller your cubes are the flakier your crust. I recommend at least cutting the sticks of butter into 4 and then chop into small cubes from there. Add the cold cubed butter to the flour mixture. Measure out cold water and have ready.
  • Turn mixer on low, slowly start to incorporate all ingredients. Gradually turn mixer to medium speed, once the butter mixture looks like wet sand immediately add in all the water. As soon as the dough comes together, stop mixer. Divide into 2 pieces, one weighing about 311 grams and the other weighing about 170 grams. Form each piece into a disk and wrap in plastic wrap. Allow to cool in the fridge for at least 6 hours or overnight.
  • Preheat the oven to 350°F.
  • To make the filling: In a large bowl, add the Italian sausage, grated cheese, tomato sauce, green peppers, red onion, and mushrooms. Mix together and set aside.
  • Grease a 9-inch pie dish well with butter (I used a cast iron pie pan in this recipe, and it baked amazing!). Remove the pie dough from the fridge. Remove the plastic wrap and place on a floured surface. First, roll out the large disk to 1/4-inch thick, it should be about 11-inches in diameter. Place the pie dough into the pie pan and press lightly to form against the pan. It should be large enough that the dough folds right over the top. Roll out the smaller disk to 1/4-inch thick, it should be about 9-inches in diameter. Set aside.
  • Add the filling into the pie pan and spread out evenly. Top with the smaller pie dough top and crimp and fold over the edges of the dough to seal the top and bottom together. Flute the edges.
  • Bake for 70 minutes or until the crust looks slightly golden brown. We didn’t use an egg wash or anything here, so it won’t be as dark as most pies, so keep that in mind! Remove from the oven and turn the oven up to 400°F.
  • Add the remaining mozzarella cheese, pepperonis, and black olives on top and bake again for 5 minutes or until the cheese is golden brown.
  • Store in an airtight container in the fridge for up to 3 days.


YouTube video


High Altitude – Bake at 350°F for 1 hour or until the crust looks slightly golden brown. Follow the steps above and turn oven up to 400°F and bake for an additional 5 minutes or until the cheese is golden brown.


Calories: 615kcalCarbohydrates: 33gProtein: 23gFat: 44gSaturated Fat: 24gPolyunsaturated Fat: 3gMonounsaturated Fat: 14gTrans Fat: 1gCholesterol: 122mgSodium: 897mgPotassium: 301mgFiber: 2gSugar: 2gVitamin A: 1156IUVitamin C: 11mgCalcium: 350mgIron: 3mg
Want more recipes?Follow along on @mimisorganiceats for more inspiration!

Subscribe to Mimi's Organic Eats!

mimi council in the kitchen

Did you like this post?

Make sure to check out the post The Best Homemade Apple Pie Recipes, which I'm sure you'll love too! And, share it with someone who you think may also like it!


  1. Pingback: How to Make Homemade Supreme Pizza | Easy Dinner Recipes

  2. Pingback: Simple Cheeseburger Tacos | Mimi's Organic Eats

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recipe Rating